Journey · 11 steps · 11 sources

Accounting fraud and how it is found

Name: 1:1 Direct Mentoring, Interview Prep & Career Coaching
Price: 350 USD

Every accounting fraud exploits a legitimate gap between when revenue is recorded and when cash arrives. This path starts with that gap, follows it through the frauds that used it, looks at the governance that let them run, and ends with how short sellers and careful readers found them.

11 steps

Start at step 1 →

Books
Films and series
Lectures and talks
Letters

Lev lowers a heavy block marked debt into a too-small cardboard box marked not ours, beside a neat light stack marked balance sheet; a string ties the box to his ankle. — The debt is fine. It’s in the other box.

1
Start hereThe legitimate gap between profit and cash that every later step works inside.
Net income and cash flow diverge by design: revenue is recorded when earned, not when paid
Accrual profit is the economics of a period; cash is the bank account. Every difference is a timing gap that the cash flow statement reconciles.
VideoAccrual Accounting: How it Works & Why it’s #1· Accounting Stuff
2
Start hereWhere that gap shows up in a healthy business, so the unhealthy version is recognisable.
Working capital is where growth eats cash, even when the income statement looks healthy
Growth ties up cash in receivables and inventory, so model the working capital a business needs before trusting its profit.
VideoWorking Capital Explained· The Finance Storyteller
3
How it worksHow the presentation of a number can do the work before any rule is broken.
An adjusted metric is an argument about what should not count
Judge an adjustment by whether an owner of the whole business would also get to ignore the cost.
DocumentaryWeWork: Or the Making and Breaking of a $47 Billion Unicorn· 2021
4
See it happenThe gap used on purpose: recognised revenue and debt moved off the balance sheet.
Revenue recognition and off-balance-sheet vehicles can book profit that never arrives
Profit is an opinion about the future; cash is a fact. When they diverge for long, find out why.
DocumentaryEnron: The Smartest Guys in the Room· 2005
5
See it happenA fraud spotted from how smooth its returns were, years before anyone acted.
Returns too smooth to be real are themselves the evidence
A track record with no bad months is a question, not a credential.
SeriesMadoff: The Monster of Wall Street· 2023
6
See it happenA control failure: the same person making a trade and confirming it.
One person holding both the trade and its settlement is the whole failure
Whoever can take a position must not be the person who confirms it. Separate the hands, and the rest of the controls become possible.
FilmRogue Trader· 1999
7
The other sideWhy the people meant to catch it did not.
A board that accepts a narrative has stopped doing diligence
A compelling story is a claim to test, and the test for a technology is watching it work.
DocumentaryThe Inventor: Out for Blood in Silicon Valley· 2019
8
The other sideThe warning sign that is easiest to explain away.
Secrecy presented as protecting the technology is the warning sign
Protecting a secret and refusing to demonstrate a result are different things; a company that cannot tell them apart may have no result.
BookBad Blood· John Carreyrou
9
Use itWhere to read first: the notes, not the headline.
The warning was usually in a footnote, years early
Read the notes before the numbers; the disclosure that matters is usually there and usually ignored.
BookThe Signs Were There· Tim Steer
10
Use itChecking the filings against the world when the filings are in doubt.
A short seller does fieldwork because the filings are the thing in doubt
When the filings are what is in doubt, the evidence has to come from outside them.
DocumentaryThe China Hustle· 2017
11
Use itWhat that fieldwork looks like when it is written up.
The modern short report is built from local records, site visits and the filings
A short thesis is a public claim set against a fact the company does not control, with the arithmetic that joins them shown.
LetterMuddy Waters' initiating report on Sino-Forest· Muddy Waters Research

Accounting fraud and how it is found

Net income and cash flow diverge by design: revenue is recorded when earned, not when paid

Working capital is where growth eats cash, even when the income statement looks healthy

An adjusted metric is an argument about what should not count

Revenue recognition and off-balance-sheet vehicles can book profit that never arrives

Returns too smooth to be real are themselves the evidence

One person holding both the trade and its settlement is the whole failure

A board that accepts a narrative has stopped doing diligence

Secrecy presented as protecting the technology is the warning sign

The warning was usually in a footnote, years early

A short seller does fieldwork because the filings are the thing in doubt

The modern short report is built from local records, site visits and the filings

Put this journey to work

Learn the idea

Open the model

See it in live data