TechniqueCase studyAccountingFraud and forensics
The warning was usually in a footnote, years early
Tim Steer · The Signs Were There
The idea
Steer traces a series of corporate failures back to the disclosure that flagged each one, and finds that the signal was almost always public well before the collapse: a change in revenue recognition noted in an accounting policy, a related-party transaction in the notes, a growing gap between profit and cash that the cash flow statement showed to anyone who read it. The book is a forensic accounting course disguised as case studies, and its practical claim is that most frauds are not hidden so much as unread.
Read the notes before the numbers; the disclosure that matters is usually there and usually ignored.
When it works
Any model review, any quality of earnings exercise, and any short thesis.
When it may fail
Footnotes flag hundreds of innocent things for every fraud, so the technique produces questions rather than verdicts. The skill is deciding which question to spend a day on.
How to use it
Before building a model, read the accounting policies note and the related-party note in full and write down anything that changed from the prior year. A changed policy is the single most reliable early signal the book finds.
Where it came from
Book The Signs Were There · Tim Steer
What the source says. Corporate failures traced back to the disclosure that flagged them years in advance: a forensic accounting course disguised as a collection of case studies.
Connected ideas
Says something similar
Revenue recognition and off-balance-sheet vehicles can book profit that never arrivesProfit is an opinion about the future; cash is a fact. When they diverge for long, find out why.
Says something similar
Returns too smooth to be real are themselves the evidenceA track record with no bad months is a question, not a credential.
Says something similar
The modern short report is built from local records, site visits and the filingsA short thesis is a public claim set against a fact the company does not control, with the arithmetic that joins them shown.
Concepts
Put it to work on L3VLUP
More like this
- FrameworkAccountingDocumentary
An adjusted metric is an argument about what should not count
Judge an adjustment by whether an owner of the whole business would also get to ignore the cost.
From WeWork: Or the Making and Breaking of a $47 Billion Unicorn · 2021
- Post-mortemFounders and companiesDocumentary
A board that accepts a narrative has stopped doing diligence
A compelling story is a claim to test, and the test for a technology is watching it work.
From The Inventor: Out for Blood in Silicon Valley · 2019
- TechniqueFraud and forensicsDocumentary
A short seller does fieldwork because the filings are the thing in doubt
When the filings are what is in doubt, the evidence has to come from outside them.
From The China Hustle · 2017
- FrameworkAccountingVideo located
Net income and cash flow diverge by design: revenue is recorded when earned, not when paid
Accrual profit is the economics of a period; cash is the bank account. Every difference is a timing gap that the cash flow statement reconciles.
From Accrual Accounting: How it Works & Why it’s #1 · Accounting Stuff