Letters & Theses

Jeffrey Smith · Starboard Value

Starboard Value's letter to the Darden Restaurants board (July 2014)

Published 15 Jul 2014Available at SEC.govActivist letter · Investment

The view as filed on 15 Jul 2014, not a statement of what the author thinks today.

Page 1 of the proxy filing, as filed with the SEC

Page 1 of the proxy filing, as filed with the SEC

What to notice

  1. 1

    Starboard argues the board should have known the Red Lobster Sale would destroy at least $800 million of shareholder value, and likely well over $1 billion against Red Lobster's true value inside Darden.

Continue the investment thesis

See the 3 remaining takeaways on what this investor is arguing and why, and every analysis across the Letters & Theses library.

Checking what you can open…

“It is time to get back to basics: great people, great food, fair prices, and an enhanced customer experience.”
Jeffrey Smith, 15 Jul 2014

Why read it

Shows how an activist builds a proxy-contest case from value destruction, relative share performance and a sum-of-the-parts multiple analysis of what remains.

About this letter

Jeffrey C. Smith, managing member of Starboard Value, sent this letter to the board of Darden Restaurants on 15 July 2014, and Starboard filed it with the SEC as soliciting material ahead of a proxy contest for board seats at the 2014 annual meeting. It opens with a quotation from the founder, Bill Darden, on the importance of good people, and argues that the company's core values had been replaced by a corporate bureaucracy with poor leadership and excessive spending.

Starboard recalls that it had communicated its views privately and publicly since 2013, warning of the risks of jettisoning Red Lobster, the group's first brand. The letter was written after the board went ahead with the Red Lobster Sale. It covers the value Starboard believes the sale destroyed, Darden's share price record against peers, the director slate Starboard had assembled, and its view of what the remaining company is worth.

Companies

  • Darden Restaurants DRI
  • Red Lobster

Themes

  • board change
  • governance
  • breakup or separation
  • turnaround

L3VLUP does not host this document. It belongs to Starboard Value and is a public SEC filing; the notes above are L3VLUP’s reading of it.

Holdings named in this letter

Starboard Value LP’s reported 13F position in each company the letter names, in the quarter ending on or before the letter and the quarter after. Shown because the letter names the company. A letter is commentary; it is not a record of why a position changed.

  • DRI Darden Restaurants · Subject of the letter

    Before the letter
    30 Jun 2014 (Q2 2014 13F): 8,215,061 shares, reported at $380m.
    After the letter
    30 Sep 2014 (Q3 2014 13F): 11,635,000 shares, reported at $599m.

    3,419,939 more shares listed at 30 Sep 2014 than at 30 Jun 2014.

Everything Starboard Value LP reports (13F) · Every letter beside its positions