Letters & Theses

Jeffrey Smith · Starboard Value

Starboard Value's letter to CarMax's incoming CEO

Published 10 Mar 2026Filed 11 Mar 2026Available at SEC.govActivist letter · Investment

The view as filed on 11 Mar 2026, not a statement of what the author thinks today.

Page 1 of the proxy filing, as filed with the SEC

Page 1 of the proxy filing, as filed with the SEC

What to notice

  1. 1

    The letter is addressed to Keith Barr before he formally starts as chief executive, and is pitched as an offer to collaborate from a holder with about $350 million invested.

Continue the investment thesis

See the 4 remaining takeaways on what this investor is arguing and why, and every analysis across the Letters & Theses library.

Checking what you can open…

“We believe the primary issue is conversion, not demand.”
Jeffrey Smith, 10 Mar 2026

Why read it

Shows an activist laying out a turnaround plan for a new chief executive, one operation at a time, from trade-in sourcing to a numerical SG&A target.

About this letter

Jeffrey Smith, Managing Member of Starboard Value, wrote this letter on 10 March 2026 to Keith Barr, CarMax's incoming President and Chief Executive Officer, with a copy to the Board of Directors. Starboard filed it with the SEC on form DFAN14A, the form used when a party other than the company files proxy soliciting material, so a private-looking letter to one executive was also made public to every shareholder.

The letter arrives at a leadership transition, after a period in which, in Starboard's view, the used-car retailer's results fell well short of its potential. Rather than a list of demands, it walks through the business as a chain of operations: buying cars, reconditioning them, selling them, pricing and overhead. It also touches on the CarMax Auto Finance arm and the balance sheet, and treats AI as one tool for reworking workflows.

Companies

Themes

  • turnaround
  • cost discipline
  • competitive advantage
  • management change
  • ai
  • valuation discount

L3VLUP does not host this document. It belongs to Starboard Value and is a public SEC filing; the notes above are L3VLUP’s reading of it.

The same argument, elsewhere

Holdings named in this letter

Starboard Value LP’s reported 13F position in each company the letter names, in the quarter ending on or before the letter and the quarter after. Shown because the letter names the company. A letter is commentary; it is not a record of why a position changed.

  • KMX CarMax · Subject of the letter

    Before the letter
    31 Dec 2025 (Q4 2025 13F): not among Starboard Value LP’s listed positions. A holding below the listed range, under another security, or none at all would read the same.
    After the letter
    31 Mar 2026 (Q1 2026 13F): 6,201,362 shares, reported at $258m.

Everything Starboard Value LP reports (13F) · Every letter beside its positions