Letters & Theses

Scott Ferguson · Sachem Head Capital Management

Sachem Head's April 2022 letter to US Foods stockholders

Published 26 Apr 2022Available at SEC.govActivist letter · Investment

The view as filed on 26 Apr 2022, not a statement of what the author thinks today.

Page 1 of the proxy filing, as filed with the SEC

Page 1 of the proxy filing, as filed with the SEC

What to notice

  1. 1

    The valuation gap frames everything: on consensus 2024 estimates US Foods traded at about 11 times earnings and Sysco at about 17 times, a premium of roughly 50% for a peer with highly similar business models and leverage.

Continue the investment thesis

See the 3 remaining takeaways on what this investor is arguing and why, and every analysis across the Letters & Theses library.

Checking what you can open…

“Who do you believe will make US Foods deliver?”
Scott Ferguson, 26 Apr 2022

Why read it

It shows how an activist turns a peer comparison into a valuation argument, linking a margin gap and a multiple discount to specific operating and governance failures.

About this letter

Scott Ferguson signed this letter for Sachem Head Capital Management to his fellow US Foods stockholders on 26 April 2022, during a proxy contest for the foodservice distributor's board. Sachem Head beneficially owned approximately 8.7% of the company, a roughly $750 million investment, and had been invested since 2018, mostly as a passive stockholder, before nominating five candidates for election.

The letter compares US Foods throughout with its closest peer, Sysco Corporation, and argues that the company's shortfalls trace back to a board that has not held management accountable. It covers shareholder returns since the 2016 IPO, valuation, margins, operating and capital allocation decisions, the history of guidance and the failed settlement talks, then sets out the nominees' priorities and the upside Sachem Head sees, ending with biographies of each nominee.

Companies

  • US Foods Holding Corp. USFD
  • Sysco Corporation SYY

Themes

  • board change
  • governance
  • margin expansion
  • capital allocation
  • culture
  • valuation discount

L3VLUP does not host this document. It belongs to Sachem Head Capital Management and is a public SEC filing; the notes above are L3VLUP’s reading of it.

Holdings named in this letter

Sachem Head Capital Management LP’s reported 13F position in each company the letter names, in the quarter ending on or before the letter and the quarter after. Shown because the letter names the company. A letter is commentary; it is not a record of why a position changed.

  • USFD US Foods Holding Corp. · Subject of the letter

    Before the letter
    31 Mar 2022 (Q1 2022 13F): 19,184,852 shares, reported at $722m.
    After the letter
    30 Jun 2022 (Q2 2022 13F): 18,932,877 shares, reported at $581m.

    251,975 fewer shares listed at 30 Jun 2022 than at 31 Mar 2022.

  • SYY Sysco Corporation · Mentioned

    Before the letter
    31 Mar 2022 (Q1 2022 13F): not among Sachem Head Capital Management LP’s listed positions. A holding below the listed range, under another security, or none at all would read the same.
    After the letter
    30 Jun 2022 (Q2 2022 13F): not among Sachem Head Capital Management LP’s listed positions. A holding below the listed range, under another security, or none at all would read the same.

Everything Sachem Head Capital Management LP reports (13F) · Every letter beside its positions