ArgumentTechniqueAccountingValuation
Stock-based compensation is an operating expense that costs no cash and dilutes you anyway
Aswath Damodaran · Session 5: Accounting Inconsistencies
The idea
Paying employees in shares is the most argued-about line in modern accounts. It is added back in most adjusted earnings figures on the grounds that no cash leaves the company. Damodaran's argument is that it is an operating expense all the same: the company has given away part of itself to buy labour, and if it had paid cash and used the cash to buy back the shares it issued, the economics would be identical. Whether it is a cash flow is a separate question he answers directly. For a valuation the choice matters: add it back and you overstate cash flow, or count it and you account for the dilution, but not both at once.
Treat stock compensation as a cost of doing business; either deduct it from cash flow or count the dilution, and never ignore it twice.
When it works
Any technology company valuation, any adjusted EBITDA reconciliation, and the interview question about non-cash charges.
When it may fail
The two frameworks give the same value per share only when the discount rate equals the cost of equity; otherwise they differ, and the gap is a judgement the model should state rather than hide.
How to use it
In a DCF for a company with heavy stock compensation, run it both ways: expense it, or add it back and dilute the share count by the awards. The Finance OS treatment of the two frameworks shows the two values and when they agree.
Where it came from
Video Session 5: Accounting Inconsistencies · Aswath Damodaran (NYU Stern)
What the source says. Damodaran argues stock-based compensation is an operating expense, and answers whether it is a cash flow.
Connected ideas
Puts it to work
An adjusted metric is an argument about what should not countJudge an adjustment by whether an owner of the whole business would also get to ignore the cost.
Worth knowing first
Net income and cash flow diverge by design: revenue is recorded when earned, not when paidAccrual profit is the economics of a period; cash is the bank account. Every difference is a timing gap that the cash flow statement reconciles.
Concepts
Put it to work on L3VLUP
More like this
- TechniqueValuationVideo located
A capital-structure-neutral cash flow needs a capital-structure-neutral discount rate
Match the discount rate to the cash flow: a flow to all capital providers is discounted at the blended cost of all of them.
From WACC Explained · The Finance Storyteller
- FrameworkValuationVideo located
A DCF is machinery for one sentence: value is the present value of expected cash flows
Every cell in a DCF is a claim about future cash or about its risk; if you cannot say which, the cell should not be there.
From Session 3: Intrinsic and DCF Valuation — Laying the Groundwork · Aswath Damodaran (NYU Stern)
- TechniqueValuationLetter located
A sum of the parts shows what a take-private bid is paying nothing for
Value each part a bidder is acquiring; what the bid leaves at zero is the argument against it.
From Southeastern Asset Management's letter to the Dell board (February 2013) · Mason Hawkins and Staley Cates
- ArgumentDeals and M&AVideo located
Accretion is arithmetic; whether a deal was worth doing is a different question
Answer accretion with arithmetic and value with evidence, and never let the first stand in for the second.
From Session 25: Acquisition, a Value Destroyer? · Aswath Damodaran (NYU Stern)