Case studyFrameworkCreditDeals and M&ARisk
A capital structure is a set of rights people will litigate over
Max Frumes, Sujeet Indap · The Caesars Palace Coup
The idea
On a slide, a capital structure is a stack of boxes in order of seniority. In a restructuring it is a set of contracts, each with covenants, each held by people with lawyers. The Caesars fight showed what that means: assets moved between entities, creditors arguing over whether transfers were fraudulent conveyances, and the value of a claim depending as much on the document it was written in as on the business it was a claim on. The lesson for anyone modelling debt is that the waterfall is a legal argument waiting to happen, and the fine print decides who wins it.
In distress, a claim is worth what its documents let it argue for, not where it sits on the slide.
When it works
Restructuring and distressed interviews, credit modelling, and any discussion of covenant-lite lending.
When it may fail
The book is dense and the case was extreme. Most restructurings settle on the documents without the courtroom, but the settlement price reflects what the courtroom would have decided.
How to use it
When you model a debt stack, add a column for what each tranche's documents allow: asset transfers, priming debt, amendment thresholds. The recovery waterfall model is the arithmetic; the column is the law that moves it.
Where it came from
Book The Caesars Palace Coup · Max Frumes and Sujeet Indap
What the source says. A restructuring fought from the creditor side: the best introduction to covenants, fraudulent conveyance and how a capital structure gets torn apart.
Connected ideas
Says something similar
The duration and covenants of a loan matter as much as the amount of leverageAsk when the debt comes due, what it can reach, and what trips it, before asking how much there is.
Takes it further
A capital stack is a queue for losses, and the order is the whole productSeniority is a queue for losses; the thickness of the slices beneath you is your protection.
Says something similar
Private credit lends larger, with thinner coverage and lower recoveriesPrivate credit's borrowers are more levered and its recoveries lower than the syndicated market's, and the capital waiting to be deployed is what pressures underwriting.
Concepts
Put it to work on L3VLUP
More like this
- Case studyCrises and market historyLetter
In a crash, long-duration cash flows move far less than the price, if you stay solvent
State the liquidity first, because the argument that prices overshoot value is only available to those who can wait.
From Bruce Flatt's March 2020 update to Brookfield shareholders · Bruce Flatt
- FrameworkCrises and market historyFilm
A rating is a model output, and the model rests on a correlation assumption
Ask what a rating assumes about defaults happening together before trusting what it says about the pool.
From The Big Short · 2015
- TechniqueCreditVideo located
How much debt is the right amount: the cost-of-capital approach
The right amount of debt minimises the blended cost of capital; the maximum a lender will provide is a different and larger number.
From Session 18: Optimum Capital Structure — The Cost of Capital Approach · Aswath Damodaran (NYU Stern)
- Case studyDeals and M&AFilm
A management buyout puts the seller on both sides of the table
In a management buyout the insider is the buyer, so the board's job is to make the market, not take the offer.
From Barbarians at the Gate · 1993