What managers are arguing, and who agrees

Every tag comes from a closed list applied to what a manager actually wrote in a public filing, and was reviewed by a person. Shared themes are listed first: a tag two managers reach independently is worth a look, a tag one manager uses is just a label.

Each claim behind a theme is the view as filed on its date, not a current recommendation.

Elliott Investment Management LP: letters and thesesHarris Associates LP: letters and thesesJana Partners: letters and thesesRuane Cunniff & Goldfarb LP: letters and thesesSachem Head Capital Management LP: letters and thesesStarboard Value LP: letters and thesesTrian Fund Management LP: letters and theses

Reached by more than one manager

Turnaround

4 managersinvestment case

A troubled business where the thesis is repair, under new management or a new plan.

Managers: Elliott Investment Management L.P., Sachem Head Capital Management, Starboard Value LP, Trian Fund Management, L.P.

Companies: CarMax, Inc., Darden Restaurants, Inc., Phillips 66, The Procter & Gamble Company, The Walt Disney Company, US Foods Holding Corp., athenahealth, Inc.

Activist engagement

4 managersownership governance

A public campaign or engagement by the manager.

Managers: Elliott Investment Management L.P., Sachem Head Capital Management, Starboard Value LP, Trian Fund Management, L.P.

Companies: Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, Darden Restaurants, Inc., Phillips 66, The Procter & Gamble Company, The Walt Disney Company, US Foods Holding Corp.

Margin inflection

4 managersoperating driver

Margins are expected to turn, and that turn carries the thesis.

Managers: Elliott Investment Management L.P., Sachem Head Capital Management, Starboard Value LP, Trian Fund Management, L.P.

Companies: Autodesk, Inc., Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, CDK Global, Inc., The Walt Disney Company, US Foods Holding Corp., athenahealth, Inc.

Board change

4 managersownership governance

Directors added, removed or sought.

Managers: Elliott Investment Management L.P., Sachem Head Capital Management, Starboard Value LP, Trian Fund Management, L.P.

Companies: Darden Restaurants, Inc., Phillips 66, The Procter & Gamble Company, The Walt Disney Company, US Foods Holding Corp.

Sum of the parts

4 managersvaluation

Value is argued segment by segment.

Managers: Elliott Investment Management L.P., Harris Associates L.P., JANA Partners, Starboard Value LP

Companies: Darden Restaurants, Inc., EQT Corporation, Phillips 66

Multiple re-rating

3 managersvaluation

The thesis requires the multiple to rise, not just earnings.

Managers: Harris Associates L.P., Sachem Head Capital Management, Starboard Value LP

Companies: Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, Capital One Financial Corporation, Darden Restaurants, Inc., Meta Platforms, Inc., The Charles Schwab Corporation, US Foods Holding Corp.

Cost programme

3 managersoperating driver

A named, quantified cost reduction.

Managers: Sachem Head Capital Management, Starboard Value LP, Trian Fund Management, L.P.

Companies: Autodesk, Inc., Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, CarMax, Inc., The Procter & Gamble Company, US Foods Holding Corp.

Special situation

3 managersinvestment case

The return depends on a discrete corporate event rather than operations.

Managers: Elliott Investment Management L.P., JANA Partners, Starboard Value LP

Companies: Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, EQT Corporation, Phillips 66, athenahealth, Inc.

Corporate action

3 managerscatalyst

A spin-off, sale, merger or similar.

Managers: Elliott Investment Management L.P., JANA Partners, Starboard Value LP

Companies: Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, Darden Restaurants, Inc., EQT Corporation, athenahealth, Inc.

Execution risk

3 managersrisk

The plan may not be delivered.

Managers: Elliott Investment Management L.P., Starboard Value LP, Trian Fund Management, L.P.

Companies: Autodesk, Inc., Bristol-Myers Squibb Company, The Procter & Gamble Company, athenahealth, Inc.

Buyback

2 managerscapital allocation

A stated repurchase programme.

Managers: Elliott Investment Management L.P., Harris Associates L.P.

Companies: CDK Global, Inc., Charter Communications, Inc.

Management change

2 managersownership governance

A named change in senior management.

Managers: Elliott Investment Management L.P., Starboard Value LP

Companies: CarMax, Inc., athenahealth, Inc.

Every theme in the set

ThemeAxisManagersClaims
Turnaroundcase.turnaroundinvestment case49
Activist engagementgovernance.activist_engagementownership governance48
Margin inflectiondriver.margin_inflectionoperating driver47
Board changegovernance.board_changeownership governance47
Sum of the partsvaluation.sum_of_partsvaluation45
Multiple re-ratingvaluation.multiple_reratingvaluation38
Cost programmedriver.cost_programmeoperating driver36
Special situationcase.special_situationinvestment case35
Corporate actioncatalyst.corporate_actioncatalyst35
Execution riskrisk.execution_riskrisk34
Buybackcapital.buybackcapital allocation23
Management changegovernance.management_changeownership governance22
One to three yearshorizon.one_to_three_yearshorizon12
Growth at a reasonable pricevaluation.growth_at_reasonable_pricevaluation12
Divestiturecapital.divestiturecapital allocation11
Asset value discountcase.asset_value_discountinvestment case11
Volume growthdriver.volume_growthoperating driver11
Three to five yearshorizon.three_to_five_yearshorizon11
Competitive erosionrisk.competitive_erosionrisk11
Leverage riskrisk.leverage_riskrisk11